Ezra's Bookshelf

Blackshirts and Reds

by Michael Parenti · 188 pages · ~3.5 hrs

Blackshirts and Reds argues that fascism was no historical aberration but a rational instrument of capitalist power, and that the long Western campaign against communism should be understood in the same light. Michael Parenti, an American political scientist and longtime writer on the left, treats the twentieth-century conflict among fascism, communism, and liberal capitalism as a single class struggle. The book opens by reconstructing the rise of Mussolini and Hitler through political economy. Parenti emphasizes how Italian industrialists and landowners, alarmed by the gains of unions and peasant organizations after the First World War, financed the Blackshirts who attacked labor halls and cooperatives, and how German heavy industry and finance turned against the Weimar Republic and funded the Nazis, who never won an electoral majority before Hitler was appointed chancellor in 1933. In his account, the lasting achievement of both regimes was to crush organized labor and drive down wages. The book then turns to the communist states. Parenti defends what he calls siege socialism, contending that the repression and shortcomings of these societies must be weighed against civil war, foreign intervention, and economic isolation, and against their record on employment, housing, health care, and education. One chapter takes aim at left anticommunism, faulting Western radicals for holding revolutions to an impossibly pure standard. He also describes the dislocation that followed the free-market transformation of Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union after 1991. This is a polemic rather than a neutral history, and its treatment of Soviet-style repression remains sharply contested. Read alongside histories of those regimes, it offers a clear statement of a radical position that continues to find new readers.

For fans of